|
| |
"If Jesus Met the Buddha on the Road..."
by Paul A. Laughlin, Ph.D.
There is an old Zen koan or riddle that
asks, "If you meet the Buddha on the road, what should you do?" A variety of
answers have been offered to that question over the centuries, the most radical
and best known of which is: "Kill him!" Odd or outrageous as that response
sounds, given the principles of Buddhism, it makes perfect sense -- in a Zen
sort of way. But I pose to you a rather different question: "If Jesus met the
Buddha on the road, what would he do?"
That question is a timely one, for three books have appeared
recently with that very theme. The first is Vietnamese Buddhist monk Thich Nhat
Hanh’s Living Buddha, Living Christ, which draws parallels between the
spirits and teachings of the two masters. The second book, published just last
year, is Jesus and Buddha: The Parallel Sayings, by renowned New
Testament Scholar Marcus Borg, which, after a short introductory essay, merely
juxtaposes similar sayings of the two spiritual Masters. The third is The
Good Heart: A Buddhist Perspective on the Teachings of Jesus by The Dalai
Lama. These three books follow in the tradition of Two Masters, One Message:
The Lives and Teachings of Gautama and Jesus, published twenty years ago by
Canadian religion professor Roy C. Amore and documenting a century of scholarly
recognition of the incredible parallels between the careers and messages of
Jesus and the Buddha.
The parallels begin as the stories themselves do. After incredibly
long existences prior to their ultimate incarnations, both Jesus and the Buddha
were born of royal blood lines and of ritually pure and chaste women (Mary and
Maya), who had conceived miraculously following heavenly nocturnal visitations
and then gave birth while on a journey. Those births were celebrated by
celestial beings and accompanied by unusual astronomical activity, and drew wise
men from afar to behold both infants and bestow them with precious gifts. Within
a week of each birth, an old seer beheld the infant at a naming ceremony, and
predicted great things for him. Only one canonical story is told about the
childhood of each Master, and in both cases, it is of a young boy showing
amazing knowledge beyond his years.
The events in the adult lives of Jesus and the Buddha likewise show
many similarities. Both began their ministries at about age 30 with dramatic
breaks from their respective communities, families, and lives up to that point,
immediately followed by a period of self-denial and fasting in which each was
tempted by a devil to abandon the spiritual path for worldly things. Both men
then took on the role of itinerant spiritual master and teacher, living off the
hospitality of the villagers they visited, and sometimes associating with the
disreputable. Both attracted large crowds of hearers and followers, but formed a
smaller group of close disciples that itself included an inner circle. Both
Masters lived moderately -- unlike their more ascetic, self-denying spiritual
contemporaries -- and both therefore drew harsh criticism for living too
comfortably. Both commended living simply and traveling light to their
disciples, and commissioned them to spread their messages with missionary zeal.
Both reportedly walked on water, and each helped a disciple to do so through
concentration or faith; and in both cases the disciple started to sink until
assisted by the Master. Both reportedly worked miracles of multiplying food,
each healed a blind man with moisture from his own body and calmed a dangerous
and threatening storm. Each experienced a bodily transfiguration that made him
appear supernaturally radiant. Both asked for and received a drink of water from
a ritually unclean woman at a well; and both forgave and redeemed a thief. Both
had a disciple who was a slow learner, and who was later named the leader of the
community that would carry on the Master’s work. Each had a disciple who plotted
death against him.
The intentions of both Masters appear similar. Both worked within a
prevailing religious tradition and challenged and broke its rituals and rules.
Yet, neither appears to have been consciously founding a new religion, both
instead being intent on renewing the religious and spiritual climate of their
day. Nevertheless, both laid the foundation for a spiritual revolution upon
which an independent religion would be built after his death. Neither wrote any
scripture. All we know about both Masters, therefore, was what was said about
them and remembered on their lips, then written down much later, much of which
consists of pithy sayings and miraculous doings.
The messages of Jesus and the Buddha show astounding similarities.
Both were teachers, not just of ethics, but of a spiritual Wisdom that turned
the attention of their audiences within themselves. Both taught in indirect and
sometimes puzzling ways, including parables, metaphors, similes, and other
comparisons. "Way" or "Path" imagery was important in the teaching of both, as
were "Sight" and "Light." Neither attempted to make the spiritual path sound
easy: both said that their followers must give up security and worldly things
and break family ties. Both told their disciples to lay up spiritual treasures
that would be safe from theft, rather than transitory material ones. Both told
their followers to become as children.. Both commended returning hatred with
love, anger with kindness, aggression with non-violence, and stinginess with
generosity. Both denounced adultery and judgmentalism, counseled contentment
with what one has, and told their disciples not to be anxious about food,
clothing, or shelter. Both specifically used sermon illustrations involving
birds, flowers, and trees, and the sowing of seeds. Both told a story about a
rich man with a prodigal son. Both delivered a memorable sermon from a high
place.
Finally, the two met similar ends. Both reportedly died while
consciously and symbolically absorbing the evils of the world into themselves,
thus sparing those around them much misery, and both instructed their followers
to forgive the persons responsible for their deaths. The deaths of both were
cosmic events, accompanied by earthquakes. In dying, both reportedly conquered
death; thus a symbol of the death of each subsequently took on a positive
meaning and became emblematic for the religion that he inspired. Both men were
venerated as gods after their deaths.
There are differences in the life stories and teachings of the two
men, of course, as you would expect of individuals living in different cultures,
and particularly in different religious and theological milieus. But these
contextual differences really serve to make the many similarities all the more
striking.
Whatever the reasons for the parallels (still a matter of much
speculation and debate), they suggest an answer to our initial question. What
would Jesus do if he met the Buddha on the road? First, he would recognize him
as a spiritual brother or partner with much in common, including a message and a
mission. Second, they would celebrate that commonality and minimize the rest.
Third, they would learn from each other whatever they could. And finally, should
we happen along, they would encourage us to join and follow them -- both of them
-- on a single Way, one with no fork in the Path, a Road that leads within.
Marcus Borg relates the story of his experience of being in Viet
Nam during our war there, not fighting Communism, but studying Buddhism. He
tells of visiting a monastery in the Mekong Delta, built on an island by a man
of peace known simply as "The Coconut Monk." He recalls being surprised to find,
on a hill at one end of the island, two enormous 50-foot statues -- one of the
standing Buddha and one of Jesus, the two standing, embracing each other, and
smiling. "While helicopter gunships flew overhead and the war raged around us,"
he says, "Buddha and Jesus stood there like brothers, expressing compassion and
healing for all who would follow in their way." That, it seems to me, is what
would happen if Jesus met the Buddha on the road.
Thich Nhat Hanh, the Vietnamese Zen monk who has been living in
exile in France ever since that same war, says that on his personal altar he has
statues of the Buddha and Jesus. "...every time I light incense," he says, "I
touch both of them as my spiritual ancestors." "When we are still," he says,
"looking deeply, and touching the source of our true wisdom, we touch the living
Buddha and the living Christ in ourselves and in each person we meet." What
could better describe what New Thought Christianity is all about than "touching
the living Christ in ourselves and each person we meet"? And, if beholding and
touching the Buddha as well as the Christ in our imaginations can help us to
that goal of touching our inner divinity, what a good thing to do!
(Copyright 1998 by Paul A. Laughlin, all rights
reserved.)
Dr. Paul A. Laughlin is
Professor and Chair Emeritus of the Department of Religion and Philosophy at
Otterbein College in Westerville, Ohio. He is the author of Remedial
Christianity: What Every Believer Should Know about the Faith, but Probably
Doesn't (Polebridge Press, 2000) and its forthcoming sequel, Getting Oriented:
What Every Christian Should Know about the Eastern Religions, but Probably
Doesn't. He may be contacted at
plaughlin@otterbein.edu.
Note: This article has been republished in an revised form in New Thought
magazine.
|